Dealing with unidentifiable sources of uncertainty within environmental models
نویسندگان
چکیده
Sources of Uncertainty Global Assessment using Split SamplES (SUNGLASSES) is a method for assessing model global uncertainty to aid in the development of integrated models. The method is complementary to the commonly investigated input and parameter uncertainty, as it accounts for errors that may arise due to unknown or unassessable sources of uncertainty, such as model hypothesis errors, simplifications, scaling effects or the lack of the observation period to represent long-term variability and fluctuations in the system. Such sources are typically dominant for most environmental models and they undermine the reliability of environmental models. The SUNGLASSES algorithm directly estimates the overall predictive uncertainty without identifying or quantifying the underlying sources of uncertainties. The method uses the split sample approach to generate an estimate of model output uncertainty by selecting a threshold below which model simulations are determined to be acceptable. Where this methodology differs from other methods that use a threshold, is that the threshold is determined by evaluating the confidence bounds on model outputs during an evaluation time period of data that was not used to initially calibrate the model and generate parameter estimates. Where parameter uncertainty is often assessed using some goodness-of-fit criterion such as the mean squared errors, SUNGLASSES focuses on a criterion that evaluates the correctness of the model output values to be used directly in decision making, such as total mass balance assessments or violations of standards as imposed by legislation. The described method is applied to the integrated water quality modelling tool, SWAT2003, applied to Honey Creek, a tributary of the Sandusky catchment in Ohio. Water flow and sediment loads are analysed. The incorporation of the split sample approach in the methodology produces a reasonable error bound that captures most of the observations during both the initial calibration period and during the evaluation period.
منابع مشابه
Evaluating Approaches to Dealing with Uncertainty in Environmental Assessment
Uncertainty of environmental impacts is a major factor limiting the effectiveness of environmental assessment (EA) and is likely to increase in importance with the introduction of mandatory Strategic EA in the EU. A synthesis and evaluation of approaches to dealing with uncertainty was found to be lacking in the literature. Approaches to dealing with uncertainty in EA were identified from liter...
متن کاملModelling Uncertainty and Variability in Environmental Systems
Scientists from different disciplines now routinely work together on complex, multi-interactive, geochemical and biochemical environmental processes and it has become necessary to define a common language that can be understood by all the relevant scientific community. This in turn will aid the transfer of expertise between scientists from different disciplines. This paper attempts to relate di...
متن کاملUncertainty Estimation in Stream Bed Sediment Fingerprinting Based on Mixing Model
Uncertainty associated with mixing models is often substantial, but has not yet been fully incorporated in models. The objective of this study is to develop and apply a Bayesian-mixing model that estimates probability distributions of source contributions to a mixture associated with multiple sources for assessing the uncertainty estimation in sediment fingerprinting in Zidasht catchment, Iran....
متن کاملFuzzy efficiency: Multiplier and enveloping CCR models
Comparing the performance of a set of activities or organizations under uncertainty environment has been performed by means of Fuzzy Data Envelopment Analysis (FDEA) since the traditional DEA models require accurate and precise performance data. As regards a method for dealing with uncertainty environment, many researchers have introduced DEA models in fuzzy environment. Some of these models ar...
متن کاملAn Adaptive Weighted Fuzzy Controller Applied on Quality of Service of Intelligent 5G Environments
in computational intelligence area, it is suitable to fulfill the analysis in order to interpret the concept and sources of uncertainty and the conditions of its incidence, and hence pursuit for reliable techniques of dealing with it. Dealing with uncertainties in this case is a challenging and multidisciplinary activity. So, there is a need for a capable tool for modeling, control, and analyti...
متن کامل